28 February 2017  | 
TVGuide.co.uk ranks The Greatest TV Shows Ever

American Idol Comments
Submit Comment

Your Comment Title

Your Comment
Your NickName
(will be displayed on TVGuide)

I love la porsha renae americian idol 2016.
Uzi 7:05pm Thu 10 Mar
Report Abuse

american idol
I love nicki minaj
oreo 1:57pm Fri 5 Apr
Report Abuse
jessica sanchez by far is the best in her group, nobody even comes close to her amazing talent. watch her on youtube and you'll konw exactly what i'm talkin about. she can sing pretty much anything this girl i'm tellin ya
kevin 9:59pm Wed 21 Mar
Report Abuse
Ryan Seacrest is...
...HOT!!!! :-p
Brody 1:38pm Fri 20 Jan
Report Abuse
American idol
Katy Perry's performing tonight!!!!
JoJo 11:25am Thu 21 Apr
Report Abuse
Is this the top 12 results???????
georgiaa 9:48pm Fri 18 Mar
Report Abuse
They may need to be found but why not find them first, then put them on TV.
myview 10:30pm Sat 5 Mar
Report Abuse
Keep going, good show
Of course you have to sieve peoples voices out, but there are always one or two really nice voices that have to be found.
Positive view 12:44pm Sat 5 Mar
Report Abuse
american idiot
interviewing the idiots is the only good part of this mush.
get real 10:07pm Sat 26 Feb
Report Abuse
SHINME 6:46pm Sat 26 Feb
Report Abuse
American idle: vacuous inane insincere...I love the Atlantic ocean
The Judges! table steals the show for me, it oozed charm and personality, but what happenned to the ejector seats that were in the first draft for the show
Eva Sublime 1:09am Sat 19 Feb
Report Abuse
Loving the comments
Be a contestant on next years American idol, be a saddo. I agree with pokerpete entirely. justin Bieber is a little know it all and i think telly is going to pot.
Pok3y 3:53pm Mon 31 May
Report Abuse
so this is what young girls watch
god help us
pokerpete 9:57pm Thu 27 May
Report Abuse
No hope for the future
If this asinine tripe is the best that America can produce, the future for pop music looks very bleak.
myview 10:31am Thu 20 May
Report Abuse
American trash
Standard Bearer 5:23pm Wed 19 May
Report Abuse
justin bieber
is justin bieber on there 2 dayy?
beieber 1:55pm Tue 18 May
Report Abuse
American Idol
Mine would be Osama bin Mohammed bin Awad bin Laden
USSR 5:04pm Sat 8 May
Report Abuse
Where are the results tonight?? the programme got cut off!!
syhala 10:02pm Thu 6 May
Report Abuse
lady gaga
omg is lady gaga on this tonight plyss some 1 answer XX
bb 7:50pm Wed 5 May
Report Abuse
Lady GaGa
is lady gaga on american idol tonighttt?
Larissa 7:44pm Wed 5 May
Report Abuse
Lady GaGa
Will Lady GaGa be on this show today, if not what day and time will she appear
rusty 5:10pm Wed 5 May
Report Abuse
I watch this....
.... because I have no life.
c 10:30pm Mon 3 May
Report Abuse
love this
OMG i love this
stretch 7:41pm Thu 8 Apr
Report Abuse
looking for tittle of song
please help looking for the tittle with the song that has love,love, love in the lyrics it was sung several times please help
mitch 7:22am Thu 25 Feb
Report Abuse
American Idiot
Ha ha I made that up myself.
Johnny Come Lately 6:05pm Sat 30 Jan
Report Abuse
joe jonas
mrs joe jonas 10:30pm Wed 27 Jan
Report Abuse
I'm SOOOOOO Excited to see Joe Jonas on it!! AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
OHYES 10:13pm Tue 26 Jan
Report Abuse
you can understand why americans are disliked?, cocky & full of themselves.
tosser 6:43pm Mon 25 Jan
Report Abuse
i cant wait to see avril in it
rob 4:19pm Sun 24 Jan
Report Abuse
I have the american factor ;)
gemma t 9:37am Fri 22 Jan
Report Abuse
Oh nooooooooo..............
Can´t bear the screaming hyenas in the audience !!!!!!!!
grumpyoldwoman 9:11pm Thu 21 Jan
Report Abuse
Say not more.
Master Bates 8:38pm Wed 20 Jan
Report Abuse
I thought Victoria was great on the show - she actually compliments Simon! She is down to earth and honest with her comments - just like Simon, but not as sarky!!
Olicanalady 6:25pm Thu 14 Jan
Report Abuse
the way Simon treats Victoria with such contempt. What does she know anyway, the weak link in spice girls. She should be on here as a contestant, a definate NO from everyone.
ed 8:20am Thu 14 Jan
Report Abuse
good i love the show x
lady e 6:03pm Wed 13 Jan
Report Abuse
New Series
Can't wait for this series to start! I think Ellen is gonna be such a laugh :D ...although I am gonna miss Paula :(
SarahMc 9:45pm Sat 9 Jan
Report Abuse
Swiss Idol
I've had enough
N Dittal 11:10pm Wed 4 Nov
Report Abuse
American Idol
Should be American Idiot.
les 8:57am Sat 23 May
Report Abuse
Watch Adam Lambert!!!!!
If you don't usually watch American Idol, there is one very big reason why you should now - Adam Lambert. This guy is absolutely amazing, never heard anyone sing like him, he gives you shivers. He is a superstar already.
Starhunter 8:03pm Thu 23 Apr
Report Abuse
American Idol
It is a very interesting program but it gets harder and tougher all the time..........
Pretty 3:21pm Thu 16 Apr
Report Abuse
Pass It On
We'd Like To Hear, SUSAN BOYLE Sing MEMORY From CATS!
AM 8:34am Thu 16 Apr
Report Abuse
Fuller Can you explain this term please??
BO 10:34pm Fri 10 Apr
Report Abuse
Adam to win!
I watch the show just to see him. He is as entertaining as Rhydian used to be on the British version.
fan 8:01pm Thu 9 Apr
Report Abuse
Americans...so dramatic! lol
T-t-t-t-t 10:41pm Thu 12 Mar
Report Abuse
Boy what a bunch of tards in here. Any of you graduate daycare?
Fuller 9:14am Tue 24 Feb
Report Abuse
mixed bag!
Thankfully Simons in on it calming them all down!Should be named-Cringe Idol. Who is 'plastic' Kara anyway!? Nevertheless-great entertainment whilst no other singing contest are on tv at the mo. Candidates not as good as last yr tho. Would love to see a Band Contest next. Why dosent anyone do it!? Apart from 'unsigned act' that is!?
zo 2:26pm Fri 20 Feb
Report Abuse
Danny Goket FTW!!!
CastroCookie 5:38pm Thu 19 Feb
Report Abuse
Flucking yanks..
X factor is bad enough, but an American version!? Don't make me vomit.
Samwise 8:12pm Sat 14 Feb
Report Abuse
Both x-factor and American Idol would be not worth watching unless Simon Cowell was present. He inspires the programmes with his honest constructive viewpoints. Well Done Si!!!!
Kalvi 11:57am Sat 14 Feb
Report Abuse
i think the show is good i love it so much
kim 10:18pm Fri 13 Feb
Report Abuse

Read all TVGuide users comments on American Idol.  

Press Esc to close
Subscribe to our Daily Highlights Newsletter:
New Series This Week
Gap Year
The Secret Chef
The Secret Life of the ...
1066: A Year to Conquer ...
The Replacement
Play to the Whistle
TV Highlights
2:00amFear the Walking Dead
6:30pmGreat Continental Railway ...
8:00pmThe Secret Life of the ...
9:00pmThe Replacement
9:00pm24 Hours in A&E
10:00pmInside No 9
Top Catchup TV
1The X Factor Results
2The X Factor
3Live UEFA Champions League
4Match of the Day 2
5Match of the Day
6Strictly Come Dancing
7Sports Personality of the ...
8Strictly Come Dancing: The ...
9MasterChef: The Professionals
10The Royal Variety Performance
1Coronation Street
6Home and Away

Most Discussed
1Coronation Street
3Bargain Hunt
5Loose Women
6Tipping Point
7This Morning
8Antiques Road Trip
9Midsomer Murders
10Snake Boss
Highest Rated
1Our Dancing Town9.0
2Snake Boss9.0
3Live EFL8.5
4Ronnie O'Sullivan's ...8.7
5Portrait Artist of ...9.0
6Saving Hope9.3
7Honey I Bought the ...9.0
8Carp Wars8.2
9Code Black8.3
10Rick and Morty9.4
Latest Blog Entries
27 FebREVIEW: The Walking Dead S7 E11 ‘Hostiles and Calamitie
27 FebThe Oscars 2017: Full winners list
27 FebThe Voice UK photoshoot snaps released ahead of ...
27 FebTwitter reacts to The Oscars giving out the wrong ...
27 FebThe Only Way Is Essex start date confirmed
24 FebKim Woodburn comforts Marnie Simpson after split ...
24 FebWatch Mel and Sue in Let’s Sing and Dance for Comic ...
24 FebLove Actually sequel will see Rowan Atkinson reprise ...
24 FebThe Cilla Black musical to open in Liverpool later ...
24 FebLove Island’s Terry Walsh and Emma-Jane Woodhams ...
TV Listings | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | ADVERTISE | FAQ | PRIVACY | © 2017 TVGuide.co.uk Ltd TV Listings. All right reserved & trademarks acknowledged. Now in 50 Countries!