20 November 2017  | 

FilmSaving Private Ryan Comments
Submit Comment

Your Comment Title

Your Comment
Your NickName
(will be displayed on TVGuide)



Shaving Ryan's privates
the film was ok but the book was tastier according to Roland Rat
Mikey Mayous 8:08pm Fri 18 Oct
Report Abuse

Rating
7.6
 
     
Yeehaw!
One of the best War films ever made...not to put too fine a point on it...I like it. Would like to see the same from Blighty and the Ruskies on a similar level of quality.
Monty 9:43pm Fri 3 Aug
Report Abuse
 
     
Amazing
Despite what people say about the cast and plot, this is an amazing interpretation on the events that may have happened on D-day. Well done
fgiuo 11:30am Thu 5 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
shaving ryans privates
was better
what the 12:08pm Sun 25 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
brilliant
best war movie ever made
tony the t.v. oracle 6:47pm Sat 24 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
gung ho!
lets send in a lot of troupes to save one. the all american heros, or idiots.
bloke downt pub 9:19am Sun 5 Jun
Report Abuse
 
     
Anne - "Fake rubbish"
And yet Britain keeps kissing USA's ar*e. its an embarrassment and Britain is becoming a laughing stock.
david 4:40am Sat 4 Jun
Report Abuse
 
     
Quite simply..
One of the best films ever made.
Steven Breen 4:56pm Fri 3 Jun
Report Abuse
 
     
To RICK
correct but he failed operation market garden the largest air invasion bigger than normandy which involved the british also. so he can be over rated
Matt Damon 11:24am Mon 16 Aug
Report Abuse
 
     
Good film but ...
surely Tom Hanks was too young to be fighting in world war II? bit of a plot flaw ...
Gary Goober 6:27pm Sun 15 Aug
Report Abuse
 
     
You'd think the Americans won the war on their own
Tom Hank's character says, "I think that Montgomery is over rated." Montgomery spent two years planning D-Day and the French invasion. He also beat Rommel in North Africa. Which must make him one of the greatest Generals of WWII if not of all time.
Rick 9:41pm Tue 10 Aug
Report Abuse
 
     
Yes It Is Good- But!
I think The Thin Red Line, portrays, the greater individual torment of the youngmen who went to war
Ciarano 10:22pm Sun 14 Mar
Report Abuse
 
     
On reflection
I've changed my mind.
Quality Film Fan 9:44pm Sun 28 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     
Another Hollywood Movie
After the first dramatic 15 minutes, this film settles down to a typical Hollywood jingoistic war movie. There have been far superior war films made for the cinema, but they will never be seen on TV by the general public, because they have not been commercially made for Hollywood. Try Stalingrad by Mullner or Ivan’s Childhood by Tarkovsky.
Quality Film Fan 8:13pm Sun 28 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     
Great Film
The best and possibly most realistic war film ever. As to the other posts the war was won primarily by the Russians. More people died in the battle of Stallingrad than all the other Western battles put together for the whole war...
RobP 6:49pm Sun 28 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     
fact
commonwealth troops did feature in band of brothers - americans saving paras from the Arnhem disaster -
ted 5:37pm Sun 28 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     

Didn't you know that the Americans won the war out-right? I think there were a few other allied soldiers about, but America did the main bit... :P
4:16pm Sat 6 Jun
Report Abuse
 
     
Terrible
No cosideration for British or Commonwealth troops in this film. Hanks also did this in Band of Brothers.
rich 8:06pm Thu 4 Jun
Report Abuse
 
     
Outstanding!
Simply the best D-Day movie ever-with the best opening sequence of any war film (ever)
Andy S 9:20pm Wed 3 Jun
Report Abuse
 
     
Hanks at his best
Hanks at his best
zed 5:16pm Thu 18 Dec
Report Abuse
 
     
<3 LoveThisFilm
This film is great...x ;]
ILoveFilm 7:36pm Wed 16 Jul
Report Abuse
 
     
S.P.V
Possibly one of the best dam film in the world, and definatley the best war film. although the first 20 mins are not for the faint hearted...
richie 11:30pm Sat 7 Jul
Report Abuse
 
 

Read all TVGuide users comments on Saving Private Ryan.  

Press Esc to close
Subscribe to our Daily Highlights Newsletter:
New Series This Week
Today
Claimed and Shamed
The Sheriffs Are Coming
Armchair Detectives
The Pets Factor
The Simpsons
Sinkholes: Buried Undergroun
7 Little Johnstons
Would I Lie to You?
TV Highlights
12:45amEstranged
1:00amLife Below Zero
2:00amTaskmaster
2:00amLife Below Zero
8:00pmUniversity Challenge
8:00pmSupergirl
8:30pmWould I Lie to You?
9:00pmI'm a Celebrity Get Me ...
9:00pmMade in Chelsea
9:00pmCriminal Minds
Top Catchup TV
1The X Factor Results
2The X Factor
3Live UEFA Champions League
4Match of the Day 2
5Match of the Day
6Strictly Come Dancing
7Sports Personality of the ...
8Strictly Come Dancing: The ...
9MasterChef: The Professionals
10The Royal Variety Performance
Soaps
1Coronation Street
2EastEnders
3Emmerdale
4Hollyoaks
5Neighbours
6Home and Away

Most Discussed
1Coronation Street
2Bargain Hunt
3Emmerdale
4Breakfast
5This Morning
6Antiques Road Trip
7Money for Nothing
8Tipping Point
9Celebrity Antiques Road Trip
10EastEnders
Highest Rated
1Louis Theroux: My ...8.8
2Best Laid Plans8.6
3The Vietnam War8.5
4David Gilmour: Live ...9.8
5Guy Martin's WWI Tank9.2
6Curvy Brides Boutique9.9
7The Big Family Cooking ...7.7
8Eight Days That Made ...9.0
9The Good Doctor9.7
10Ancient Top Ten10.0
Latest Blog Entries
19 NovREVIEW: Crimes That Shook Britain tackles horrific ...
18 NovAmp up the action with Jean-Claude Van Damme movie ...
16 NovREVIEW: Norman Reedus invites Jeffrey Dean Morgan ...
15 NovYouTube star Zoella apologises for offensive tweets ...
15 NovI’m A Celebrity…Get Me Out Of Here! reveals exciting ...
14 NovCompetition: Win Victoria season 2 on DVD!
14 NovThe Best Telenovelas And Where To Watch Them In ...
14 Nov5 Reasons Why Telenovelas Are Better Than Soaps
14 NovNegan attacks Gabriel and hints there could be major ...
13 NovReview: The Walking Dead S8E4 ‘Some Guy’ showcases ...
TV Listings | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | ADVERTISE | FAQ | PRIVACY | © 2017 TVGuide.co.uk Ltd TV Listings. All right reserved & trademarks acknowledged. Now in 50 Countries!