18 October 2017  | 

     
FilmStar Trek Comments
Submit Comment

Your Comment Title

Your Comment
Your NickName
(will be displayed on TVGuide)



Not actually bad...
...but has plot holes large enough to fly a fleet of Romulan Warbirds through.
Shilliam Watner 8:00am Mon 20 Oct
Report Abuse

Rating
8.5
 
     
Epic failure
Zachary Quinto as young Spock is compelling but everything works against him and the entire film crashes and burns a hundred times.
Footnote 8:30pm Tue 29 Apr
Report Abuse
 
     
where no man has gorn B4
its a larf, and worth a watch. clever casting - but remember folks its fiction...hahahaha!
seinfeld 7:06pm Mon 4 Jun
Report Abuse
 
     
Lensflare Trek
Living proof sad trekkies will watch any old piece of trash. Absolutely dire rubbish and a complete waste of money.
Trek is Trash 7:40pm Sun 18 Dec
Report Abuse
 
     
2nd best Star Trek after Khan
This is a fantastic film it came out the same year as Avatar and is a much better film imo ,ignore the people trying to tell you its rubbish their talking nonsense i mean just look at the viewer rating
The Great andPowerful Turtle 7:33pm Sat 8 Oct
Report Abuse
 
     
Repeats, Repeats, Repeats, Repeats ...
Not again!!! Who are there schedulers? A deaf, dumb and blind man man could do better.
Warlock 6:18pm Sat 8 Oct
Report Abuse
 
     
what an amasing film
10/10 for this one.
tail lift 7:27pm Mon 3 Oct
Report Abuse
 
     
AWFUL
Had been looking forward to this, but having seen it i can honestly say it is one of the worst films i have ever seen, just bad in every department. ABSOLUTELY DREADFUL.
TOPWAK (THE VOICE OF REASON) 7:37am Mon 3 Oct
Report Abuse
 
     
good presentation
worth a watch.
stars 5:22pm Thu 29 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Star trek XI
It's essentially the battle seequence from revenge of the sith stretched out for 100 mins(they sy so on the dvd) with 20 mins of random events thrown in as a stroyline. The plot(what there is of it): Romulus gets destroyed, the bad guy from nemesis gets sent back in time to before the original series era and now has the most powerful ship in the galaxy. Does he try to conquer? NO. Does he try to save Romulus(his home planet)? NO. Instead he sort of waits around for 20 odd yrs then destroys Vulcan. The new Enterprise : For a start it seems to have shrunk and now consists of only 3 parts. The bridge, tiny and looks like a leftover from a washing machine advert. The shuttlebay, an old hangar or studio with a set cheaper than the one from star wars. The engine room, here they didn't even try. It's a concrete bunker full of pipes, with no engineers or even an engine. The new crew : seemed quite good from what i could tell(they weren't there much), I especially liked Karl Urban as bones but his total screen time was about 60 seconds. Plot holes you can drive a starship through, ridiculous random events(sorry leutenant this random cadet is now captain), cheap sets, a highly engineer and advanced starship thas was previously made by skilled engineers with unknow equipment is now made by sweaty men with welding gear and I could easily go on. All about the cgi and an insult to your intelligence 0/10
Why? 4:36pm Thu 29 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Star trek original
Fantastic!!!!!!!!!! A great series. Dodgy studios and effects, but good for the time. The story lines seem better than today!!
Katter 10:58pm Fri 19 Mar
Report Abuse
 
     
Entertaining but drivel
Not a shade on the original. Young Kirk is a born again moron whilst the plot is unchallenging, disappointing and somewhat predictable. Could have been so much more. 2 out of 10 for trying.
Kerrji 9:14pm Wed 30 Dec
Report Abuse
 
     
"Propaganda"
propaganda propaganda propaganda propaganda propaganda propaganda
Microsoft Paperclip 3:50pm Sat 5 Dec
Report Abuse
 
     
Alien commander
Mark Lenard, not Mark Leland.
NickyK 9:45pm Fri 4 Dec
Report Abuse
 
     
Thumbs up
Aww Yeah
Reece Hinton 12:13pm Fri 3 Apr
Report Abuse
 
     
fantastic
kirky at his best
malaga 3:08pm Thu 5 Feb
Report Abuse
 
 

Read all TVGuide users comments on Star Trek.  

Press Esc to close
Subscribe to our Daily Highlights Newsletter:
New Series This Week
Today
Ugly House to Lovely House ...
DC's Legends of Tomorrow
Army: Behind the New Frontli
Storage Wars Canada
Obsessive Compulsive Country
Long Lost Family Australia
Positive Energy
Tomorrow
Arrow
TV Highlights
12:05amPayback
1:00amLife Below Zero
2:00amLife Below Zero
9:00pmThe Apprentice
9:00pmDoc Martin
9:00pmStella
9:00pmTaskmaster
9:00pmOrange Is the New Black
10:00pmLife Below Zero
11:00pmLife Below Zero
Top Catchup TV
1The X Factor Results
2The X Factor
3Live UEFA Champions League
4Match of the Day 2
5Match of the Day
6Strictly Come Dancing
7Sports Personality of the ...
8Strictly Come Dancing: The ...
9MasterChef: The Professionals
10The Royal Variety Performance
Soaps
1Coronation Street
2EastEnders
3Emmerdale
4Hollyoaks
5Neighbours
6Home and Away

Most Discussed
1Coronation Street
2Bargain Hunt
3Emmerdale
4Antiques Road Trip
5EastEnders
6Breakfast
7Good Morning Britain
8Casualty
9Flog It!
10The X Factor
Highest Rated
1The Big Family Cooking ...8.3
2Britain's Lost Masterpiec9.3
3Best Laid Plans8.9
4Louis Theroux: Dark ...9.3
5The Vietnam War9.2
6George Michael: Freedom9.8
7Russia with Simon ...8.7
8Edge of Alaska10.0
9Handmade9.9
10Live European Rugby ...9.9
Latest Blog Entries
18 OctGame of Thrones actress Lena Headey accuses Harvey ...
18 OctGBBO GIF RECAP: Who won Star Baker and who left ...
18 OctTOWIE: First-look photos suggest Megan McKenna and ...
17 OctWhen can I watch X Company on HISTORY?
17 OctThe Walking Dead star claims season 8 will resemble ...
17 OctLiar will return for series 2
17 OctMade In Chelsea: Watch Tiff and Mimi battle over ...
17 OctCrimewatch is cancelled
16 OctWhen can I watch WW2 Treasure Hunters on HISTORY?
16 OctEXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Disney stars Booboo Stewart ...
TV Listings | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | ADVERTISE | FAQ | PRIVACY | © 2017 TVGuide.co.uk Ltd TV Listings. All right reserved & trademarks acknowledged. Now in 50 Countries!