7 December 2021  | 
HELLO

   
Silent Witness Comments

Bizarre
They get worse each episode. Writers must be used to comics.
Davey 9:01pm Mon 4 Oct

Rating
4.8
 
   
Dated
Nothing new and refreshing. Tired old storylines.
Jenny 9:19pm Tue 21 Sep
 
   
Clap trap.
Pathetic crap for Philistines.
us 7:46pm Tue 21 Sep
 
   
Outrageous
This story was absolutely ridiculous. Who writes this stuff? It is not the bl**dy USA!
Martin 9:02pm Tue 7 Sep
 
   
Wait for series 9
These early series were renowned for the terrible acting of Amanda Burton. A plank of wood could not have shown less emotion or less acting ability.
Gran 1:43pm Tue 2 Jun
 
   
Theme music
Nmmewm series but if only they had dropped that haunting song.....gives me the creeps and adds nothing!
mazza 10:17pm Tue 15 Jan
 
   
Burnt body
I have seen this one before about the woman in the burnt out car. The close up on the slab was horrific to see and I remember how gory it was in the beginning. However that does not excuse the "cloud cuckooc plots they are showing in the new series.
don'tbelieveallyouread 11:32am Mon 26 Feb
 
   
Why
Would Nikki's character go chasing through the woods when there was supposedly a gunman at large?? Thought after last weeks episodes it was getting more watchable. But seems I was wrong
confused 11:37am Tue 6 Feb
 
   
Melodramatic
I can't be doing with this anymore. Nikki the forensic scientist OTT again with her emotions. She needs to sort out out a career move asap.
don'tbelieveallyouread 9:36pm Mon 5 Feb
 
   
Unbelievable
Rediculas storyline.. As if??
Andy 11:04pm Mon 30 Jan
 
   
Second Time Around
You find how mplausable this was. eg a Forensic Scientist (Nicky) gets attacked and can only remember a strange smell. It turned out to be the smell from alcohol breath.....so much for an "expert". Even moi could identify that!
once more 8:43am Mon 10 Oct
 
   
dna testing
The forensic scientist obtain a sample from a child in a play area while undercover while the parent is unaware......is that legal??
once more 10:43pm Sun 1 Feb
 
   
Why
must it always be about foreign diplomats and espionage in this type of show.......so baffling and boring
once more 9:33pm Tue 27 Jan
 
   
Really?
Ridiculous plots, lazy writing with inconceivable leaps of logic to solve crimes, unauthentic, corny dialogue, terrible acting. Can't wait for the next one.
Watched 10:22pm Wed 7 Jan
 
   
Confused
What exactly is Jack's profession? I thought he was a pathologist! If that is the case why was he so heavily involved in the tracking down and capture of the suspects, surely this would not be allowed in the 'real world'
confused 9:56am Sat 25 Jan
 
   
unconvincing
two thirty something asian men wait outside school gates and then take two schoolgirls in uniform shopping in broad daylight. The story subject is real enough but the culprits are more subtle than that which is how they are getting away with it for so long.
doubletake 10:36pm Sun 19 Aug
 
   
A story too far
Shot in the leg, walking within minutes, no blood loss... LOL really, defies belief. Someone, somewhere is very desperate for a story lines. Woefully abysmal
Oblomov 10:42pm Mon 7 May
 
   
As others have said.
All getting way too far-fetched. Earlier series were much better (once Amanda Burton and her wooden acting had gone) and a return to feasible plots would be well received.
Dai Laffin 2:30pm Sun 6 May
 
   
To far fetched
This programme has now entered the realms of the silly season. The writer should be hung. You stumble across a road accident, and you don't think to phone for an ambulance? Then you go of to a house, without contacting the police or again an ambulance, and there's twoo of you!!!! Totally rediculous.
Crumhorn 10:16am Tue 24 Apr
 
   
totally unprofessional
I know this is a work of fiction but Leo's action.... drummed out of the profession within seconds..the one man crusade... ROFL.. and the anger.. from a professional "scientist" No way Jose
Oblomov 11:35pm Mon 23 Apr
 
   
Snore
Wake me when its over I got lost in part one
brockle 5:37pm Mon 9 Apr
 
   
Could it get any worse?
The worst acting and continuity in all the series, ever!! What's going on with Silent Witness? Love the series usually, hate these 2 episodes. Is there a learner director and editor let loose? hhrrrumppff.
Cattmint 9:13pm Tue 1 Feb
 
   
No No No
This is the worst acting of the whole series.
Dances with mice 10:17pm Mon 31 Jan
 
   
Is this a joke?
Worst acting in this series ever. Come on BBC !!!
Hammy 9:13pm Mon 31 Jan
 
   
yawn
Stagnant, repetitive guff
Ay Nal Probe 4:57pm Mon 3 Jan
 
   
Contrived
Contrived unbelievable complexity. Not as good as last series.
abubbler 10:08pm Thu 7 Jan
 
   
watched but bemused
can anyone explain what happpened in this episode as I am a bit lost
tippi 3:47am Tue 7 Oct
 
   
hoping to watch...
love this programme.... although sometime gets a bit boring but most of the time it is a good watch especially on a wednesday night when there is nothing else on!!
other fan 7:30pm Wed 1 Oct
 
   
silent bystander
part 1 really caught my eye, not quite a csi but quite similar. modern technology mixed with english attitude made this a very watchable programme, cant wait for tonights episode!!!
Tharman 12:30pm Tue 9 Oct
 
   
Silently subtle
I love Nikki in this i think she and Harry should get together before she leaves next series
fan 9:09pm Mon 8 Oct
 
   
hipp-hipp-hippocrates
I haven't seen this episode, but the wonders of technology allow me to express an opininion anyway. I predict it will be dull and unimaginative, possibly verging on the patronisingly racist, and will definitely be scientifically naive. But I may well be wrong. Bring back Amanda Burton.
vacuous 8:51pm Mon 10 Sep
 

Write a review







 

Read all TVGuide users comments on Silent Witness. Scroll to the bottom to submit your own comment.  

 

 

Press Esc to close
Subscribe to our Daily Highlights Newsletter:
New Series This Week
Today
Oxford Street 24/7
Secret Life of the Forest
Dog: Impossible
Landscapers
Visionaries: Eli Roth's ...
I Like the Way U Move
Tomorrow
My World Kitchen
TV Highlights
2:30amMade in Chelsea
3:25amThe 100
3:30amFear the Walking Dead
8:00pmLove Your Garden
9:00pmI'm a Celebrity Get Me ...
10:35pmI Like the Way U Move
Top Catchup TV
1The X Factor Results
2The X Factor
3Live UEFA Champions League
4Match of the Day 2
5Match of the Day
6Strictly Come Dancing
7Sports Personality of the ...
8Strictly Come Dancing: The ...
9MasterChef: The Professionals
10The Royal Variety Performance
Soaps
1Coronation Street
2EastEnders
3Emmerdale
4Hollyoaks
5Neighbours
6Home and Away

Most Discussed
1Clean It, Fix It
2Bargain Hunt
3Tipping Point
4Strictly Come Dancing
5Live: Winter on the Farm
6The Repair Shop
7Miriam and Alan: Lost in ...
8Michael McIntyre's The Wheel
9Outback Car Hunters
10The Tournament
Highest Rated
1Villages by the Sea8.8
2The Wild Gardener8.4
3Teeny Tiny Creatures9.7
4How9.1
5This Cultural Life9.0
6Plane Reclaimers9.3
7The Stonehenge Enigma: ...9.9
8The Real Prime Suspect8.8
9Live F1 Pro Series9.5
10Live: Winter on the ...9.9
Latest Blog Entries
1 DecThe best additions to Disney+ in December 2021
1 DecThe best additions to Netflix in December 2021
7 NovREVIEW: National Geographic’s Lost Treasures of ...
4 NovExplore Ancient Egypt’s greatest mysteries with ...
11 OctNo one is safe in chilling Coronation Street trailer ...
1 OctThe best additions to Netflix in October 2021
16 SepRECAP: Gordon Ramsay’s Uncharted – How the celebrity ...
12 SepREVIEW: Gordon Ramsay: Uncharted returns for a bigger, ...
7 SepCoastline crimes are coming in new Murder by the ...
31 AugThe best additions to Netflix in September 2021
TV Listings | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | ADVERTISE | FAQ | PRIVACY | MANAGE CONSENT © 2021 TVGuide.co.uk Ltd TV Listings. All right reserved & trademarks acknowledged. Now in 50 Countries!