I've said that from the start. Wooden and blank. Sykes has more personality!
troy 4:29pm Wed 16 Sep Report Abuse
Time to stop watching
Will someone tell Neil Dudgeon to try acting please? When faced with a problem he screws up his mouth and that’s it. You’d never be convinced by him that there had been a violent murder. I can’t bear to watch anymore.
Disappointed viewer 4:19pm Wed 16 Sep Report Abuse
Disappointed as thought give it another go. Nettles was the only Barnaby for me. His cousin lacks charisma and tbh rather wooden in his acting. Ever changing sidekicks with little rapport so unlike Troy, Scott and Jones with the boss. Guess this will be deleted but heh ho!
gina 8:09pm Sun 13 May Report Abuse
bring back nettles cant s
bring back john nettles cant stand the new one and only whatch the old ones
crystal 7:02pm Sun 13 May Report Abuse
Sedate easy viewing
Didn't bother watching it for years, although Mum enjoyed it & I enjoyed Terry Wogan's jokes about it on R2. Finally starting watching it after they filmed where I worked. Yes, it's sedate, middle of the road drama, but it's decent enough. All the cast are pretty good, although I prefer Nettles & Jones/Troy.
dd 10:54pm Tue 1 Aug Report Abuse
Is a far far better actor than the wooden characterless dudgeon , he should have stayed on and and wooden top retired
Caroline 10:17pm Wed 15 Feb Report Abuse
The new Inspector Barnaby
Neil Dudgeon is so much better in the role than John Nettles was. Nettles was like a robot.
peggysue 6:49pm Sun 5 Feb Report Abuse
Neil Dudgeon was a very poor choice to replace john nettles. He is simply not good enough, humourless, plodding, robotic, and that pause each time before he speaks....is he waiting for someone to whisper the limes I his ear?? Can he not be replaced in the near future by another Barnarby relative (please)
Charlotte 8:06pm Fri 3 Feb Report Abuse
Bring back the test card.
MC Captain Mcoy 8:36pm Sat 28 Jan Report Abuse
Dreadful prolongation of a formula that depended on brilliant acting and top scripts. Unwatchable.
BrotherJak 12:52pm Sat 5 Mar Report Abuse