15 November 2018  | 
HELLO

     
Holby City Comments
Submit Comment

Your Comment Title

Your Comment
Your NickName
(will be displayed on TVGuide)



Totally unrealistic
An incredibly stupid episode. And I fear the story line is not yet over.
Dave 9:07pm Tue 13 Nov
Report Abuse

Rating
4.2
 
     
WTF
Pardon me if I thought I was watching an episode of Poirot. Who on earth is seeing to the patients while all this is going on? Last time I heard the NHS was understaffed.
Jlo 9:02pm Tue 13 Nov
Report Abuse
 
     
Gaskell
Never thought I'd see a Frankenstein monster in a british nhs hospital. When is he going to return to his crypt? Then we can get back to normality.
gina 10:21pm Fri 12 Oct
Report Abuse
 
     
Ditch entire Gaskell arc.
Holby used to be good involving and believable drama. This whole Gaskell story arc is such unutterable garbage. The sooner they can write this completely unbelievable character out of the picture entirely the better. I get "suspension of disbelief" in drama but this is beyond stupid. When did Holby turn into yet another Australian soap?
DaveB 9:39pm Fri 12 Oct
Report Abuse
 
     
Sasha
Good one Jac, you take care of Sasha, we all love him and he needs your help. Dont let him do any thing we will all regret
Jan 8:00pm Tue 2 Oct
Report Abuse
 
     
Lock In Syndrom
It must be absolutely horrendous, a real nightmare for the sufferer. This has made me think about a condition I never eally imagined. Too painful to watch so get it done with please
lila 9:07pm Wed 26 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Stem cell story
Is anyone else bored bored bored of the story behind the stem cell and the professor being rogue? I have watched holby since it first ever started and this is really boring me. Been going for far too long, more like an episode of murder she wrote! Get a grip - how long are you trying to drag out the story? Don't you have any other ideas?
Genna 8:19pm Wed 26 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Even More Bizarre
Wtf with all the flashbacks? Btw would the young Roxanna have thinning granny hair? Get back to the nice hospital programme about patients on a ward.....that would be a novelty! If not it should be renamed The Holby Doctors of LaLaLand.
gina 4:59pm Wed 19 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Holby
Well what a stupid story line and completely insensitive to anyone who has locked in syndrome. Get back to what Holby does best .
Hazza 9:02am Wed 19 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Previous comments
I too have watched from the start but gave up a couple of weeks ago when the Sasha storyline started. Surprised his character has lasted so long.
Ex fan 10:51pm Tue 18 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Seriously!!!!
Going from bad to worse. Have watched this from the start but really!!!! Only decent one in it now is Jack....bring the old cast back before everyone switches off!!!!!
Tyson 9:23pm Tue 18 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Disturbing
Used to love Holby but tonight’s story where the nutty prof has caused locked-in syndrome on the Doctor was, quite fankly, disturbing and unrealistic. Miss the days of Mo, Eliot, Oliver etc. I’m gutted as it’s one of a few programs I enjoy on TV these days!
Loubee 8:21pm Tue 18 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Format
Far too complicated and difficult to follow
alemap 8:17pm Tue 18 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Holby City hits rock bottom
Surely the whole UK will give up watching after tonight’s dreadful episode. Seeing the stream of poor feedback looks like no one is taking comments on board. Bye bye Holby!
CW 8:13pm Tue 18 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Tonight episode
OMG What a terrible storyline tonight,so boring,who or which doc do that? Get real
T4vuk 8:04pm Tue 18 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Bizarre
The would be whistleblower is knocked down by a scatty doctor driver. How very convenient for the mad professor. Pardon me if I thought I had been watching Midsomer Murders.
gina 6:02pm Wed 12 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Dreadful
What is going on? Boring, boring, boring, stem cell storyline and cast! It's terrible. Get back to the wards with the real stories and blow the stem cell lab up.
Susie 8:00am Wed 12 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Ex fan
Agree. That professor with the experiments looks positively evil too.
gina 3:42pm Wed 5 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
Give up
Been watching from the start but am about to give up. Fed up with Fletch's family storyline as if hospital would allow his children to roam the hospital on weekly basis. Also the experimental ops! Having attended various hospitals Iover the years I have yet to meet anyone I know. But it's a regular occurrence in Holtby. Time to say goodbye.
Ex fan 2:18pm Wed 5 Sep
Report Abuse
 
     
BORING CRAP
Been watching Holby from day one but it is so poor now with the never ending poor story lines and too much emphasis on Gay story lines and extremely poor story lines I can see this being shelved
Puddycat 6:01am Wed 25 Jul
Report Abuse
 
     
Find a cure
Does anyone of importance from the show read these comments. Poor Holby is terminally ill. The F1's are awful, The neuro surgeon is awfull and the sidekick is dreadful, such poor acting, and the writing is abyssmal. For goodness sake give it an injection of quality. Bring back Mo, Joseph anyone, but get rid of the limp actors, and get some gritty writers. I could do better.
nurse 10:01pm Tue 3 Jul
Report Abuse
 
     
Bored and switched off
Whoever changed writers, get the good ones back. Get rid of the F1's and bring back the top characters. If it continues to be as dull as it is it'll be axed within double-quick time. Watched and enjoyed for years but crap for months now!
Bored fan sign's-off 8:06pm Wed 27 Jun
Report Abuse
 
     
Glad jac is back
Stories lines are boring but some of the old cast coming back.do the medical advisors know that f1's are only in departments for 4 months hint hint.
Ingrid2 5:02pm Thu 14 Jun
Report Abuse
 
     
Silly stories
Whatever is happening to Holby? Ive switched off again this week. Ridiculous storylines, and those two F1's. Really??? Thank goodness Gaskell isnt in it this week , I would have turned off earlier.
Nannyjack 7:32pm Tue 22 May
Report Abuse
 
     
Ditch Holby!
Totally given up on this now. Used to watch it every week, and record it if I was away. Loved it! But all the good characters have gone and the story lines are so unbelievably boring and dull. Time the BBC ditched Holby altogether!
exholbyfan 11:52am Mon 14 May
Report Abuse
 
     
Good this weeks episode
Much better this weeks story line good, to see the favorite stars ,had nearly given up on Holby,been watching for years
Hatter 8:10pm Tue 8 May
Report Abuse
 
     
Previous comment
I totally agree. Yet another child actor given an adult roll. It was painful to watch. As if he would be allowed to speak to senior nursing staff the way he did!! And as for doctors etc turning up for work with a hangover!!
Unbelievable 9:25pm Tue 1 May
Report Abuse
 
     
Sack the writers bring back old cast
OMG! I've watched holby for years & now finding myself falling asleep whilst it's on, it's absolutely awful, bring back Oliver, Zocia, Elliott, jac etc, sick of it, it's lost its magic
Bored holby fan 7:36pm Tue 1 May
Report Abuse
 
     
Off the boil
Used to love watching Holly but the great cast have mostly gone and the storyline has got ridiculous
AB 5:48pm Tue 17 Apr
Report Abuse
 
     
Boring far fetched storylines.
Bored of the far fetched story lines especially Mr Gaskells! I used to look forward to watching Holby but now tend to switch over to watch something more entertaining!
Bored 7:51pm Tue 10 Apr
Report Abuse
 
     
Started Watching ITV instead
After watching Holby since the beginning and looking forward to the next episode each week I am now completely bored of the Mr Gaskell and his side kick's storyline. BORED BORED BORED Zzzzzzz!!!
Sonny 2014 7:12pm Tue 10 Apr
Report Abuse
 
     
Completely baffling!
I have watched Holby for years and on the whole enjoyed it until recently. For the past few months it's got increasing heavy going. Tedious and implausible storylines. I'm actually left completely baffled after the latest episode. What on earth was/is it all about??? This show is in desperate need of new writers/likeable characters/more believable storylines etc. On the verge of giving up on Holby altogether!
Tanna 9:37pm Mon 2 Apr
Report Abuse
 
     
Holby City What the hell?
Sack the scriptwriters now. What an insult to our intelligence with the plot lines getting more ridiculous every week. A once great series is now a joke Wake up before you lose all your viewers
Mo 9:29am Wed 28 Mar
Report Abuse
 
     
Thought it couldn't get any worse
Having endured an endless stream of increasingly ridiculous events I have to admit defeat and can no longer bear to watch - doctors and nurses who seem to be able to simply leave without giving notice, a surgeon secretly delivering a child in a car park, a steady exodus of the most interesting characters, now completely out of the blue without any pre planning an unnamed unknown patient has every vital organ removed!! I cannot watch any more - I give in - the war on viewers has gained another victim.
ex watcher 8:08pm Tue 27 Mar
Report Abuse
 
     
Unbelivable
The bloody Oliver valentine saga fgs really ?? Allowed near an operating theatre and getting hold of hospital equipment showing a patients operation and wearing uniform when he is supposed to be a patient himself who writes this tripe this is now beyond boring and ridiculous not watching anymore utter crap!!
Tpoff 7:42pm Tue 27 Mar
Report Abuse
 
     
Holby
More implausable cr.p!
don'tbelieveallyouread 10:03pm Wed 7 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     
Holby City/Casualty
British drama at its best. Superb telly!
Ya 7:05pm Wed 7 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     
Stem cell tedium
OK, stem cell stuff amazing. In real life. Don't watch HC for genius BORING operations and deadpan weird doctor. With creepy "wet lab". Getting well boring now and pretty depression tbh. I have a job for all that! It's a soap - need a bit of chemistry between actors and some fun! Going to give it another couple of weeks then I'm off.
Mellyx 12:22am Thu 1 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     
Holby City
For goodness sake stop all this violence now in nearly all soaps. Very very boring going back and forth between prison and hospital. Its suppose to be a hospital drama do NOT want to see threatening violence in a prison.
Me 7:31pm Sat 6 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Holby
"The new soap drama. Anything the others can do we can do better" How's that for a spot of advertising??
don'tbelieveallyouread 8:44am Wed 3 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Ricky/Prison + inmates
Having watched Holby for years I did not like Pre xmas when shootings, deaths & losing very popular actors. Now so boring & uninteresting to watch Ric & inmates & warders & stopped watching near end as so bored. keep switching from prison/Ric then back to Oliver was so tedious! Finished with series!
Betty 9:15pm Tue 2 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
OMG
Do they have the same scriptwriters as Corrie and Eastenders? The lunatics are taking over the asylum.
Scary 8:44pm Tue 2 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Tues 2 december
Now we’re in prison. Ric needs to go. Lots of the good actors now gone or dead. Story writing poor in recent weeks.
Pc 8:23pm Tue 2 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Thurs night episode
What a load of tripe. The writers need to go a find a job writing garbage for the Labour party press office.
Crn 8:47pm Thu 7 Dec
Report Abuse
 
     
Turning off
After watching this programme since it started I'm now switching off as it's joining emmerdale/eastenders and Corrie on the dreadful unbelievable ridiculous storyline bandwagon the writers of this also are infactuated with the gay thing so rip holby you have joined the compost heap!!!
Ughhhhh 5:06pm Tue 17 Oct
Report Abuse
 
     
Politically Correct but boring
Face it, the BBC has an agenda to follow with tick boxes for PC stories - this means to Hell with the plot so long as we are forced to watch the requisite politically correct storyline.
Sandy 4:21pm Thu 25 May
Report Abuse
 
     
Mercy!
Lord have mercy - ANOTHER weird gay situation!!
Jed 5:38pm Wed 24 May
Report Abuse
 
     
hobly city
it is very powerful and it tells people different aspect of the doctors life's and patients as well
R 3:52pm Tue 9 May
Report Abuse
 
     
same sex
do we have to put up with this same sex trash, I,ve had enough, where is the off switch
oscar 8:33pm Tue 11 Apr
Report Abuse
 
     
Agenda led
Uncomfortable viewing with yet more same-sex couples hogging the show. Give us a break - most of these relationships aren't remotely believable anyway and feel more like agenda tick-boxing. Too much camp pursed lips.
Dorella 9:30pm Tue 28 Mar
Report Abuse
 
 

Read all TVGuide users comments on Holby City.  

Press Esc to close
Subscribe to our Daily Highlights Newsletter:
New Series This Week
Today
Primal Survivor
7 Little Johnstons
Beat the Internet with ...
Greatest Ever TV Blunders
Our Classical Century
Inside the Foreign Office
Live at the Apollo
Sat 17 Nov
My Lottery Dream Home
TV Highlights
12:05amThe Big Bang Theory
12:35amThe Big Bang Theory
2:00amLife Below Zero
3:45amThe Big Bang Theory
4:10amThe Big Bang Theory
7:40amWorld's Greatest Motorcycle ...
10:00amThe Big Bang Theory
10:30amThe Big Bang Theory
12:00pmBrooklyn Nine-Nine
12:00pmWorld's Greatest Motorcycle ...
Top Catchup TV
1The X Factor Results
2The X Factor
3Live UEFA Champions League
4Match of the Day 2
5Match of the Day
6Strictly Come Dancing
7Sports Personality of the ...
8Strictly Come Dancing: The ...
9MasterChef: The Professionals
10The Royal Variety Performance
Soaps
1Coronation Street
2EastEnders
3Emmerdale
4Hollyoaks
5Neighbours
6Home and Away

Most Discussed
1Butterfly
2Coronation Street
3Bargain Hunt
4Emmerdale
5Make Me a Dealer
6Operation Live
7EastEnders
8Big Brother
9Letterbox
10Loose Women
Highest Rated
1Operation Live8.7
2The Story of Wales8.5
3Ballers9.9
4Taskmaster: Champion ...10.0
5The Bi Life10.0
6World's10.0
7Murder Next Door7.6
8Harriet's Army9.3
9Border Patrol9.3
10Star Wars Freemaker ...9.3
Latest Blog Entries
10 NovNational Geographic’s Mars: Will humans make the ...
10 NovNational Geographic’s Mars and the rise of women ...
29 OctMCM 2018: Shadowhunters cast praise #SaveShadowhunters ...
24 OctThe best additions to Netflix in November 2018
16 OctThe National Television Awards 2019 longlist announced
8 OctDoctor Who’s Jodie Whittaker: What do the fans think?
6 OctINTERVIEW: Harry Potter star Rupert Grint, Luke ...
5 OctINTERVIEW: Pub Landlord star Al Murray asks ‘Why ...
26 SepDani Dyer confirms new Dyer family reality series ...
19 SepThe 70th annual Primetime Emmy Awards: The winners
TV Listings | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | ADVERTISE | FAQ | PRIVACY | MANAGE CONSENT © 2018 TVGuide.co.uk Ltd TV Listings. All right reserved & trademarks acknowledged. Now in 50 Countries!