7 April 2020  | 
HELLO
Midsomer Murders Comments
Submit Comment

Your Comment Title

Your Comment
Your NickName
(will be displayed on TVGuide)



Barnaby v Barnaby
Love them both but glad when Nelson was replaced --never quite took to him.
Oldninja 11:48am Sat 28 Mar
Report Abuse

Rating
6.2
New Barnaby & Wife
Get rid of them. Only interest in the programme with them in is Sykes. Far better actor and more interesting.
the Critic 7:28pm Tue 21 Jan
Report Abuse
Old favourites
Great to see some old faces in this medieval influenced episode. Love the detached, new pathologist, and favourites like Elaine Paige and Anite Harris
STEVIE 6:20pm Sat 30 Nov
Report Abuse
Neil Dudgeon......
Much better than Nettles IMO
Arena 1:59pm Mon 25 Nov
Report Abuse
anne boyd
i only watch it if its john nettles
crystal 1:26pm Mon 28 Oct
Report Abuse
Does the series start with episode four?
Seems to. What happened to the first three episodes?
ConfusedViewer 8:59pm Wed 21 Aug
Report Abuse
bring back nettles cant s
bring back john nettles cant stand the new one and only whatch the old ones
crystal 7:02pm Sun 13 May
Report Abuse
Plodding
Neil Dudgeon was a very poor choice to replace john nettles. He is simply not good enough, humourless, plodding, robotic, and that pause each time before he speaks....is he waiting for someone to whisper the limes I his ear?? Can he not be replaced in the near future by another Barnarby relative (please)
Charlotte 8:06pm Fri 3 Feb
Report Abuse
Glazed
Bring back the test card.
MC Captain Mcoy 8:36pm Sat 28 Jan
Report Abuse
A dud
Dreadful prolongation of a formula that depended on brilliant acting and top scripts. Unwatchable.
BrotherJak 12:52pm Sat 5 Mar
Report Abuse
Bring back John Nettles
After Bergerac relocated and changed his name I really got into Barnaby...he is the story...please bring him back...superb delivery by the Berg really grasped the Nettle
The Urbane Spelunker 2:56pm Tue 23 Feb
Report Abuse
Bring back John Nettles
After Bergerac relocated and changed his name I really got into Barnaby...he is the story...please bring him back...superb delivery by the Berg really grasped the Nettle
The Urbane Spelunker 1:21pm Tue 23 Feb
Report Abuse
Sykes
Wasn't Sykes the dog in early episodes of Doc Martin?
Dorothy 9:30pm Wed 17 Feb
Report Abuse
What is the Point?
Of Cully Barnaby and Sarah Barnaby appearing in these shows? In my view, no point at all.
Rick 3:54pm Sat 19 Dec
Report Abuse
Correct Spelling
HUMOUR in the UK-not HUMOR.
Mr.Pedantic 11:23pm Tue 24 Nov
Report Abuse
Original population?
Anyone know the original population of that wacko town? Must be near-zero by now...
Robot 7:35pm Tue 15 Sep
Report Abuse
We are the victims. Who is the culprit?
The Neil Dudgeon midsomers are terrible; all of the humor, warmth, camaraderie, smarts of the other series is gone. I've not gotten to where they have replaced Jones, but I hope the actor left the show by choice due to the horrible scripts he's been given. Suddenly he's a dunce and that dull dudgeon is so brilliant? Oh dear, the whole show is now as tasteless and unpalatable as the TV dinners the too young mrs Barnaby leaves in the oven!
Chelsea-girl 1:40am Mon 7 Sep
Report Abuse
Same old
Same old actors doing the rounds. Hamming it up beyond believe. Niamh Cusack and Harriet Walters trying to out ham one another! Neil Dudgeon is its saving grace
Sparks 6:12pm Tue 19 May
Report Abuse
Repeats
Why are Midsomer Murders repeats & when was The Calders biscuit edition last seen
Cath 11:21am Sat 5 Apr
Report Abuse
Too graphic
Some of the scenes are far too graphic before the watershed. Spoils a good programme. No need for it Very gratuitous
Scallywag 8:52pm Wed 26 Feb
Report Abuse
"A Hard Act To Follow"
It was always going to be incredibly hard to follow John Nettles, and Neil Dudgeon doesn't really pull it off, and his wife is FAR too young and pretty for him. Troy and Jones were really as irreplaceable as Nettles, though of course Jones did a good job of replacing the peerless Troy. RIP George, the pathologist - he brought a lot to the show, as did the people who wrote the music. Watch 10 minutes without the music and you realize how brilliant it is.
KlaatuWithGort 7:37pm Mon 17 Feb
Report Abuse
Disappointed
The new Barnaby lacks the personality and charisma of John Nettles. In fact I find him and his new partner wooden. Jones was the reason I was still watching!
bemused 4:24pm Thu 13 Feb
Report Abuse
Dull
The show has lost its sparkle. John Nettles Barnaby and now Jones has gone. Sykes is the only worth watching!
bemused 10:05pm Wed 5 Feb
Report Abuse
lost it
The show has lost it humor. The new guy does not fit the role. I think this is the last time I will watch, shame as it was always my favourite detective show.
JC, Croydon 9:32pm Wed 5 Feb
Report Abuse
Very poor lighting on new series
The lighting is So dark and flat, horrible green cast on interior scenes make this program unwatchable.
gmr73 9:08pm Wed 5 Feb
Report Abuse
Doe
What is the point of the dog ? Also Barnby far too old to pull of new baby story
Doe 8:41pm Wed 5 Feb
Report Abuse
New Midsomer Murders
What has happened to the lighting? It's terrible! We cannot watch it now and have to turn it off
Pads 6:20pm Thu 9 Jan
Report Abuse
aaah
Neil Dudgeon excellent sidekick looks like Hitler but the b lue lighting filter makes me switch off
disappointed 9:34pm Christmas Eve
Report Abuse
jones
whats happened to jones
nijinski 6:19pm Christmas Eve
Report Abuse
I need the script for
"The Black Box" Season 12 Ep 2...I think. Where can I get the script?
Sandee 12:58am Sun 22 Dec
Report Abuse
Death of a Beloved Series
I have adored this show, and cannot believe what has hapenned to it since John Nettles and Brian True-May have left. All the inherent charm and humor are gone, replaced by mediocre plots and distasteful characters.
Fluffy 4:21pm Wed 26 Jun
Report Abuse
Big Star
Who played Sykes?
Sorley 8:40pm Tue 16 Apr
Report Abuse
John Nettles
His photo is incorrect it belongs to another actor
TVHolic 10:39pm Sat 9 Feb
Report Abuse
Jason aka DS Ben Jones
I love Midsomer Murders. Brilliant acting and fantastic cast though am disappointed to hear that Jason Hughes is leaving..am gutted as I think he's very cute.
Claireeee 6:55pm Mon 21 Jan
Report Abuse
Classic TV
So not everything scene and action is strictly correct - its fiction!! I for one have really enjoyed these latest two episodes just like the old ones. It is so quintessentially english.
bemused 11:03pm Wed 9 Jan
Report Abuse
Flawed.
Yet another ludicrous plot, but I like the actors, including Sykes. Badly lit, and far too much reflector use giving everyone flashing teeth. Why is it that even with a lethal injection they always expel the air from the syringe, maybe for the same reason that all divers are deemed to use oxygen. Ignorance.
cpochin 10:18pm Wed 9 Jan
Report Abuse
Photo
Wrong photo AGAIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!
cpochin 10:22am Sat 15 Dec
Report Abuse
Last Nights Episode
I don't mind the actors, but the plots are getting a bit thin.
Sirtim 12:40pm Wed 26 Sep
Report Abuse
arrrrrrrrrrrrrr
I wish hurry up, and make some more episodes, it sooo fustrating!! All my Tv shows have stopped now, like csi, and sherlock holmes!! I wish they wouold bring back midsomer murders--sooooooooooooooooooon
I like Poirot 11:42am Wed 22 Aug
Report Abuse
Confusion!!
Why isn't there more information regarding old and new Barnaby's and consistency of days when the programme is shown. I'm confused and recording out of date programmes rather than the new and more interesting versions?
Molly 7:39am Wed 22 Aug
Report Abuse
Don't knock it - I love Midsomer
I live in Midsomer and... oh there's a knock at the door - I'll be back in a minute....
Neighbourless Bob 9:12pm Tue 21 Aug
Report Abuse
@Cherry
I have to disagree with that statment...I think Jones(Jason Hughes) is a great actor. I also, however think the dog is pretty funny! I LOVE midsomer murders, and i am devastated they have stoped filming-i hope they re-start, very SOON!
well, well, well... 10:23pm Mon 20 Aug
Report Abuse
jlm
Dreadful acting, especially Jones. The dog can do better. Each episode worse than the previous one.
cherry 8:12pm Thu 9 Aug
Report Abuse
How I adore it so...
I LOVE MIDSOMER MURDERS! I was a bit sceptical about the new Barnaby, but i realy have a-taken to like him! Great actors, and i love Sykes, the dog so i can't wait for the new series to be bak on!!!!
tally!!! 5:51pm Sun 15 Jul
Report Abuse
sick as a dog
That dog looks fed up, his acting skills are wooden and at the end of this episode he was yanked twice on his lead by Barnaby. Not cricket!
doubletake 10:05pm Wed 4 Jul
Report Abuse
should have gone a long time ago
i think midsomer murders should have been put to rest before now john nettles was very good as tom barnaby neil dudgeon is not right for the part dont know how he got to be chief inspector half the village had to be killed off before he could work it out who the killer was
kev 7:49pm Sun 24 Jun
Report Abuse
repeats, repeats
there even repeating the new Barnaby Midsommer now. I must have seen some of the old Barnaby ones three/four times over in recent times.
doubletake 1:08am Mon 18 Jun
Report Abuse
Repeats
It would be nice if repeats showed the date originally broadcast!
Betseylee 7:07pm Tue 12 Jun
Report Abuse
Love it!
Haven't had series 15 yet, but loving series 14. Although I enjoyed john Nettles, I find the new Barnaby quirky and refreshing. Carry on... Midsomer!!!!!!
Chribyn 8:37pm Tue 20 Mar
Report Abuse
Years
Is there anybody left alive in Midsomer after all these years.
brockle 3:46pm Tue 21 Feb
Report Abuse
 

Read all TVGuide users comments on Midsomer Murders.  

Press Esc to close
Subscribe to our Daily Highlights Newsletter:
New Series This Week
Today
Pointless
Major Crimes
Digging for Britain: The ...
Your Home Made Perfect
The Art Mysteries
The Yorkshire Vet
The Good Doctor
The Great Celebrity Bake ...
TV Highlights
12:00amTaskmaster
12:00amMade in Chelsea
4:00amThe Big Bang Theory
4:25amThe Big Bang Theory
4:50amHow I Met Your Mother
5:15amHow I Met Your Mother
7:00amHow I Met Your Mother
7:30amHow I Met Your Mother
10:00amThe Big Bang Theory
10:30amThe Big Bang Theory
Top Catchup TV
1The X Factor Results
2The X Factor
3Live UEFA Champions League
4Match of the Day 2
5Match of the Day
6Strictly Come Dancing
7Sports Personality of the ...
8Strictly Come Dancing: The ...
9MasterChef: The Professionals
10The Royal Variety Performance
Soaps
1Coronation Street
2EastEnders
3Emmerdale
4Hollyoaks
5Neighbours
6Home and Away

Most Discussed
1Bargain Hunt
2Breakfast
3Five Bedrooms
4Richard Osman's House of ...
5Contagion
6The Chase
7Dancing on Ice
8The One Show
9Tipping Point
10Ready Steady Cook
Highest Rated
1Babylon Berlin9.8
2Manifest9.8
3Elle9.4
4I am Frankie9.5
5From Andy Pandy to ...9.7
6Tee and Mo9.4
7Lifebabble10.0
8Scotland's Scenic ...9.4
9Top Wing9.1
10Dragons: Race to the ...8.9
Latest Blog Entries
6 AprIntroducing The Big Poll, a new Amazon Alexa Skill
3 AprThe ultimate quiz: New TV trivia packs released ...
23 MarHere’s everything you can watch on Disney+
17 MarThe 10 top rated 2019-2020 box sets you can watch ...
2 MarWhat is Disney + and how can I start watching?
27 JanThe best additions to Netflix in February 2020
14 JanWhen does Sex Education return for series 2?
11 DecBLAZE: Here’s how to watch hit TV shows for free
25 NovThe best additions to Netflix in December 2019
18 NovCompetition: WIN a £50 Amazon voucher by taking ...
TV Listings | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | ADVERTISE | FAQ | PRIVACY | MANAGE CONSENT © 2020 TVGuide.co.uk Ltd TV Listings. All right reserved & trademarks acknowledged. Now in 50 Countries!