18 July 2018  | 

The Great British Bake Off Comments
Submit Comment

Your Comment Title

Your Comment
Your NickName
(will be displayed on TVGuide)

Mel and Sue
They think themselves funny............but they are so not!
get real 12:14pm Boxing Day
Report Abuse

World Gone Mad
"It has been confirmed that the presenters of The Great British Bake Off, Mel Giedroyc and Sue Perkins, will NOT be going to Channel 4" . What!! This was breaking news on nationwide television.........sorry, short intake of breath, I thought at the very least they must have been in some horfific car crash or something!!!
once more 8:12am Sat 17 Sep
Report Abuse
The death knell has been sounded on this nonsense. It's off to Channel 4 and all the presenters are leaving.
Mr Kiplng 12:13pm Wed 14 Sep
Report Abuse
Hollywood is the best - love him :)
GBBO 4:29pm Wed 31 Aug
Report Abuse
GBBO Mel & Sue are fab :)
Love Mel & Sue they are hilarious :)
GBBO 4:20pm Wed 31 Aug
Report Abuse
Make Mary, Mel and Sue Redundant
They put me off the lovely cakes!
A 8:07pm Sat 28 Nov
Report Abuse
Hair nets
Need to be showing better hygiene practices on this programme really. Hair nets are a must.
ChooChoo 8:12pm Wed 30 Sep
Report Abuse
are you not accepting comments on this show. I have been trying for days now
unbelievable 10:58pm Sat 26 Sep
Report Abuse
Please! Reign in Mel and Sue they bring nothing to the programme. Tonights performances were cringe- worthy to say the least. I would go s far as to say they will lose the programme views if they continue
confused 8:25pm Wed 10 Sep
Report Abuse
I totally agree with your comments on Mel ans Sue. But not quite sure what you meant by 'A Very English Show'
confused 10:23am Thu 28 Aug
Report Abuse
Mel and Sue
Bake off is a great and very English show, but why on earth are Mel and Sue there?! Their self-satisified patronising brand of private humour seems to amuse each other but is totally nauseating for everyone else. Makes me cringe.
Graham 8:41am Thu 28 Aug
Report Abuse
Love the show
but was in two minds about watching it as Mel & Sue are soooooo!!! irritating. What is the point of them being there????
irritated 9:57pm Wed 13 Aug
Report Abuse
The winner is...
Strange decision ?
music fan. 10:38am Wed 23 Oct
Report Abuse
Mel and Sue
Why are they there? They're not amusing and they sometimes seem to prevent the bakers from getting on with their baking. Please get rid of them for next season!
desmotic 5:14pm Tue 22 Oct
Report Abuse
next time
hope that mel and sue are somewhere else
o dear 6:17pm Sun 20 Oct
Report Abuse
Great turn off!
Agree with last comment,the reason I do not view is because of sue and Mel they are not Funny!
Disappointed viewer 7:37am Thu 3 Oct
Report Abuse
great show
agree about sue and mel waste of time and not needed
missy 10:45pm Tue 24 Sep
Report Abuse
Enjoying the show
But- What is the point of the two female presenters very irritating
taylor 11:09am Fri 30 Aug
Report Abuse
Great Britain bakers
It underlines what we already knew, that Britain is a nation of not only bakers but cooks as well.
Monument 1:01pm Tue 27 Aug
Report Abuse
we do have very good bakery.
Our food is awful- up there with the worlds worst... But we can bake like no one else.
nin 3:20am Wed 10 Oct
Report Abuse
Good TV
@Weary : I see where you are coming from but I have to disagree! It is good as it is, the only show where the judging seems real and no over the top editing. Masterchef has gone a different route and now it sucks eggs and if you want this to change thats the only route it can take. Stay as you are British Bake off... Best show on TV for ages!
sparky 2:57pm Tue 9 Oct
Report Abuse
This is such a good show!
Hinton 3:59pm Tue 18 Sep
Report Abuse
I thoroughly enjoyed the first series because it was refreshing and querky. But the second series has become formulaic and the judges and presenters seem to exude their comments in a condescending manner. I'm afraid this may get churned out year after year like the Apprentice, or the great british menu and rapidly lose its appeal.
Tbone 5:57pm Tue 30 Aug
Report Abuse
diet destructor
lovely food
123 12:39pm Tue 16 Aug
Report Abuse
which is which?
if mel is the one wwearing the glasses, which i think she is, one of the contestants called her sue lol. i have trouble telling them apart and im probably wrong but its confusing. like the early days of ant and dec lol
breen baker 5:10pm Tue 26 Oct
Report Abuse
Thomas's bake together
After not baking a cake for many years due to losing confidence, my husband and I so enjoyed this wonderful programe we have make a start and have begun to try our hand at baking together. Thank you for your wonderful tips. We have so enjoyed cooking a lovely victoria sponge and scones and even an apple tart using apples from our one apple tree.
thomas the tanks 9:41pm Tue 21 Sep
Report Abuse
scones more like rolls
we tried the scone recipe and they were rotten...never heard of using bread flour for a scone..uugghh apart from that prog is good..
teuchter 8:53pm Thu 16 Sep
Report Abuse
david chambers
ah thank you, has he got a flatcap on too?x
me 3:57pm Thu 9 Sep
Report Abuse
I have now started baking! Thanks to this programme and how cute is Paul
Breadcrumbs 1:12pm Thu 9 Sep
Report Abuse
Lemon Buns (I think)
Does anyone know the recipe for the sticky lemon buns from last weeks program, they looked lush but I cant find anything similar.
fairlybadmother 4:30pm Tue 7 Sep
Report Abuse
David Chambers is his name
David the bakers surname is Chambers, he's wearing sun glasses in his facebook picture.
Davey 4:21pm Tue 7 Sep
Report Abuse
anyone know this david fella's surname i'm trying to find him on facebook x)
me 4:51pm Thu 2 Sep
Report Abuse
No secret ingredients?
Why can't they make a weed cake or something useful like that...
dropout 8:35pm Tue 31 Aug
Report Abuse
MyAuntie :)
My auntie Jas Randhawa is on the show and she is amazing :D i do like all the other cooks aswell and i love the show, makes me hungry though !!
SimiR 6:58pm Mon 30 Aug
Report Abuse
A lovely pair....
Great to see Sue & Mel back together again - more of same if you please! Really enjoying the programmes 8-)
cupcake-sue 7:40pm Sun 29 Aug
Report Abuse
TV Gold
Love the people and the little bits of insight. This is what reality TV should be for. Sweethearts! :D
Saara 1:40am Sat 28 Aug
Report Abuse
where are they
nutty 11:01am Wed 25 Aug
Report Abuse
Mel... or is it?
What happened to Mel's face? She's unrecognisable! Not "bad" exactly, just utterly and completely different!
Trabia 8:28pm Tue 24 Aug
Report Abuse
Totally hooked on this program, what a great recipe it is! Watched by mistake and am now addicted - that's cake for you!
Alex C 10:16pm Sun 22 Aug
Report Abuse
Mouth Watering....
Love this show when not gigging and such baking delights and talent...always makes me hungry
SaraLilly 11:32am Sat 21 Aug
Report Abuse
Loved the show, the cakes looked superb. Felt so sorry for Mark when he got upset.
Merry 2:09pm Wed 18 Aug
Report Abuse
Loved it
What a great programme really enjoyed it x
julezb 11:39pm Tue 17 Aug
Report Abuse
A great start to this show...Mel & Sue are perfect on here...
Flyingfingers 9:39pm Tue 17 Aug
Report Abuse
Cakey galore!
There is nothing better than a bit of cakey which was proven tonight (except for the beetroot one - not sure about that)
Lyndi 9:08pm Tue 17 Aug
Report Abuse
Fab progamme
Ive just had to replace my Hummingbird bakery cook book because daughter pinched the first, now Im wanting to go and bake cakes for the kids lunch boxes after watching this programe
Fairly Bad Mother 9:01pm Tue 17 Aug
Report Abuse
happy days
pure baking brilliance!
Lola 8:24pm Tue 17 Aug
Report Abuse
ahhhhhhhh amazihg i want to be on it
dee 8:22pm Tue 17 Aug
Report Abuse
No Idea if this is Even Tolerable, but...
Mel & Sue, together again at last! Woo!
roo 8:04pm Tue 17 Aug
Report Abuse

Read all TVGuide users comments on The Great British Bake Off.  

Press Esc to close
Subscribe to our Daily Highlights Newsletter:
New Series This Week
Tue 17 Jul
Beach Live: Jurassic Coast ...
Inside the Factory
The Five Billion Pound ...
Mark Kermode's Secrets ...
Long Lost Family
Cooper's Treasure
TV Highlights
Top Catchup TV
1The X Factor Results
2The X Factor
3Live UEFA Champions League
4Match of the Day 2
5Match of the Day
6Strictly Come Dancing
7Sports Personality of the ...
8Strictly Come Dancing: The ...
9MasterChef: The Professionals
10The Royal Variety Performance
1Coronation Street
6Home and Away

Most Discussed
1Coronation Street
3Bargain Hunt
4Good Morning Britain
7Love Island
8Antiques Road Trip
9Loose Women
10Holby City
Highest Rated
1Who Is America?8.7
2Murder Uncovered9.7
3Taskmaster: Champion ...10.0
4Dragons: Defenders ...9.7
5The Mistletoe Promise10.0
7Who'd Be a Billionaire9.3
8Star Wars Freemaker ...9.3
9Border Patrol9.3
10A Walk in the Sun9.4
Latest Blog Entries
17 JulMegan McKenna to get dirty in new series Celebs ...
17 JulLove Island’s Samira reveals Georgia was the “most ...
17 JulLove Island fans are convinced Georgia’s insult ...
17 JulJodie Whittaker wants to inspire girls with Doctor ...
16 JulLove Island SPOILERS: Surprise couple axed tonight?
16 JulOfcom will not investigate Love Island over Dani ...
16 JulLove Island star Ellie Brown says Jack Fincham will ...
11 JulLove Island spoiler: New girl Alexandra takes two ...
11 JulSophie Turner reveals emotional goodbye to Game ...
11 JulCaroline Flack thinks Andrew Brady is “full of lies” ...
TV Listings | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | ADVERTISE | FAQ | PRIVACY | MANAGE CONSENT © 2018 TVGuide.co.uk Ltd TV Listings. All right reserved & trademarks acknowledged. Now in 50 Countries!