24 May 2018  | 

The Magicians Comments
Submit Comment

Your Comment Title

Your Comment
Your NickName
(will be displayed on TVGuide)



Love it The Magicians on 5star Fantasy Drama
This show is great for anyone into fantasy fiction, it's Hogwarts for grownups!
Zanoni 12:55pm Sun 12 Mar
Report Abuse

Rating
4.4
 
     
Wrong Magicians!
All these reviews are for the BBC show The Magicians, not the new U.S. fantasy drama The Magicians which I thought seemed quite promising with decent acting and some great visual effects; certainly better than the 4.2 score it seems to have inherited from the other show.
Freakscene 2:23am Sat 14 May
Report Abuse
 
     
Awful
The format of this show is terrible and with the Z list celebrities they manage to find makes it even worse/
a2b 7:19pm Sat 11 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     
its great
i i like bary and stuart the best then latimer i dont like pete firman that much because he always loses
hapy bunny 6:27pm Sat 4 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     
magic my a........
Rubbish cack
ace of diamonds 5:02pm Sat 4 Feb
Report Abuse
 
     
its tricks
not magic but sooo boring.
bb 4:17pm Sat 28 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
???
how come no one notices it ?
lolbbz 6:18pm Sat 29 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
I broke wind
and no one noticed. Does that make it magic ?
Gerald Poopledunk 7:32pm Sat 22 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Oh dear..
ive just paid my 145.50 for this top saturday night entertainment! with lenny (not funny)henry, rolf (u know what it is it yet) harris! and dappy...i can't wait!!! ZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz......
Lordelpmeh!!!!! 5:41pm Sat 22 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Great show!
Sorry but I don't understand the critisism of this show - it's great family entertainment. So much better than most new entertainment shows that come along!
magicfan 8:31pm Sat 15 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Really not good
Slow moving, could easily condense this into 30mins even then there would have to be nothing on the other side, as it`s a poorly conceived programme idea
Joanne 4:16pm Sat 15 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
really poor...
so so bad, Almost as bad as Reality "celeb" obsessed TV shows. Kudos has to be given for at least attempting to make a family show, but this was so lacking any substance and content to make it a good hit!.... BBC really need to sort out Saturday night Prime Time shows, But now the Tories are in and everyone is going to get taxed to within 10 pence of poverty the BBC will be reducing budgets and making less new shows. expect it to get a lot worse!!!!
shameful BBC 9:53am Sat 15 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Spellbound
I agree - great family show, people have misjudged this series. Really fun.
coolmum 6:25pm Mon 10 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Brilliant
Brilliant show - Great family entertainment, my kids love it too. Lighten up!
miketeevee 6:20pm Mon 10 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Worst TV Show I have ever seen
And to think we actually pay our license fee for this stuff. This show lacks any substance. There is absolutely no point to this show its the least entertaining thing I have ever sat through and wont be watching again. Its weak magicians are supposed to create suspense this show had nothing. I think I might start listening to the radio again on a Saturday night as the whole Saturday line up on every station is so poor.
redd09 9:15pm Sat 8 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Insulting
This show is unbearable to watch and completely insulting. As license payers why are we being served up this utter rubbish during prime time television. BBC you should be ashamed of yourselves. Where did you dig Lenny Henry up from and since when was this sort of magic 'current' - hardly David Blaine!?
Welsh Poet 8:01pm Sat 8 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Paul Daniels
Bring back Paul Daniels - much better presented, much better show, much better tricks.
doodah 6:44pm Sat 8 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Don't be so po-faced!
The show is great, went to filming of an episode and the illusions were stunning. I'll definitely be watching the whole series, bring on series 2!
Sally Elastic 11:41am Fri 7 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
First five minutes were bad
..Sobored after that I turned over!
TallDam 3:14pm Wed 5 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Dreadful
It's really a special achievement to drain the magic out of a magic show. Old, old tricks, poorly presented,this show represents everything that's wrong with magic, one to avoid at all costs.
2Dogs 4:13pm Mon 3 Jan
Report Abuse
 
     
Runny Bottom
"Has been" presenter, format older than the dino's - one to miss. Please not mor eof this rubbish in 2011
Syball 8:32pm New Years Day
Report Abuse
 
     
Runny Bottom
"Has been" presenter, format older than the dino's - one to miss. Please not mor eof this rubbish in 2011
Syball 8:31pm New Years Day
Report Abuse
 
     
Pathetic
2011 Saturday Night Peak Viewing - It does not come any worse than this. Even the 1970's had better TV than this dross
Grommit 8:22pm New Years Day
Report Abuse
 
     
The Magicians
A absolutely brilliant show. I went to see this while filming and there is some really stunning stunts included. DON'T MISS IT!!
Oman 4:07pm New Years Day
Report Abuse
 
 

Read all TVGuide users comments on The Magicians.  

Press Esc to close
Subscribe to our Daily Highlights Newsletter:
New Series This Week
Sun 27 May
Total Bellas
Mon 28 May
Countryfile Spring Diaries
Garden Rescue
Furiki Wheels
Richard Osman's House ...
Curious Creatures
Springwatch
TV Highlights
12:00am
Top Catchup TV
1The X Factor Results
2The X Factor
3Live UEFA Champions League
4Match of the Day 2
5Match of the Day
6Strictly Come Dancing
7Sports Personality of the ...
8Strictly Come Dancing: The ...
9MasterChef: The Professionals
10The Royal Variety Performance
Soaps
1Coronation Street
2EastEnders
3Emmerdale
4Hollyoaks
5Neighbours
6Home and Away

Most Discussed
1Coronation Street
2Bargain Hunt
3Emmerdale
4EastEnders
5Carnage
6The Royal Wedding: Prince ...
7Holby City
8Breakfast
9Antiques Road Trip
10Gogglebox
Highest Rated
1Harry Hill's Alien ...8.1
2Unikitty8.8
3Riverdale9.3
4Escape to the Chateau: ...8.1
5Monkeys: An Amazing ...10.0
6Carnage7.9
7Edge of Alaska10.0
8Dragons: Defenders ...9.7
9Robocar Poli9.8
10Who'd Be a Billionaire9.3
Latest Blog Entries
23 MayJameela Jamil confirms Tahani Al-Jamil was the mutual ...
23 MayMaya Jama addresses problematic tweet in podcast ...
22 MayTOWIE’s Chloe Sims reveals all about her romance ...
22 MayAriana Grande posts heartfelt message one year after ...
21 MayThe Good Place’s Jameela Jamil was told she was ...
21 MayCOMPETITION: Win a KINDLE and a signed copy of Pure ...
18 MayREVIEW: Murder by the Sea is the true and terrifying ...
18 MayMegan McKenna hits back at online trolls calling ...
18 MayAriana Grande breaks silence on Manchester terror ...
17 MayKim Kardashian accused of being “terrible and toxic ...
TV Listings | ABOUT US | CONTACT US | ADVERTISE | FAQ | PRIVACY | © 2018 TVGuide.co.uk Ltd TV Listings. All right reserved & trademarks acknowledged. Now in 50 Countries!