Coronation Street fan theory predicts Sarah’s pregnant with Gary’s baby

Sarah and Gary are clearly keeping a secret
Tamzin Meyer

Sarah Platt and Gary Windass are clearly harbouring a secret together in Coronation Street, but what is it?

At Bethany’s birthday meal last night (Thursday, June 4), Sarah had to up and leave due to not feeling well.

Could this be because she’s pregnant thought? A new fan theory has predicted just that.

Coronation Street's Sarah upset
Sarah felt ill (Credit: ITV)

Sarah felt under the weather in Coronation Street

Yesterday on the cobbles, Sarah’s day took a worrying turn as she began feeling increasingly unwell during what was meant to be a family celebration.

Earlier, Bethany went to the salon for a birthday hair appointment with Maria, keen to mark her special day in style. She later admitted she didn’t have much planned, and was left mortified when it became clear her own mum had forgotten her birthday, with Gail’s card only arriving in the post.

Gary was quick to step in and defend Sarah, becoming noticeably protective as tensions rose. He urged the family to ease off her, pointing out she had only just suffered a head injury and was still recovering.

Later, at a last-minute birthday meal arranged by Nick, the family gathered to celebrate Bethany. She opened her presents, including a last-minute gift from Sarah, although she seemed more pleased with Jodie’s offering.

However, the atmosphere shifted sharply when Jodie brought up Theo’s murder. Sarah suddenly said she felt sick and quickly excused herself, leaving the meal and heading home early.

Don't miss a single story! Add us as a Preferred Source in Google for all your Coronation Street news

It's important to us that you never miss our articles when searching for stories! We have all the latest TV news & schedules to share with our community of loyal readers. Click here and tick TVGuide.co.uk to ensure you see stories from us first in Google Search.

Once back at the house, Sarah was confronted by more drama when Kit arrived and updated her on the discovery of Todd’s phone found in a skip at the builder’s yard. Despite feeling unwell and clearly shaken, Sarah tried to defend Gary’s innocence, but Kit remained convinced he had killed Theo, leaving her visibly unsettled and struggling to cope.

Coronation Street's Gary serious
Could Gary be Sarah’s baby daddy? (Credit: ITV)

Coronation Street fan theory ‘works out’ Sarah’s pregnant with Gary’s baby

Sarah and Gary are keeping a secret about Theo’s murder night, and they’ve both been acting rather suspiciously. Jodie even heard Sarah on the phone to Gary and predicted that something was going on between them.

Fans have been wondering for a while whether Gary and Sarah slept together that night, but with Sarah now feeling ill and being rather protective of Gary, a new fan theory has predicted that she might be pregnant with his baby.

On X, the theory read: “Is Sarah pregnant? She’s not feeling well… But with Gary’s baby, if the rumours of an affair are true?”

If this is the case, this news could turn both Maria and Kit’s worlds upside down. But, is Sarah pregnant? What are Gary and Sarah hiding?

Read more: Coronation Street star Calum Lill welcomes first baby with partner Roberta