Celebrity Traitors' Joanne McNally made a SECOND slip-up that could see her banished but did you spot it?

What on earth was she thinking?
Natasha Rigler

Celebrity Traitors Faithful Joanne McNally made a second mistake at the Round Table that went unnoticed by her co-stars.

Joanne unwittingly put a big target on her head by agreeing with Ross Kemp that the most recent face-to-face murder was “horrible”.

The Irish comedian wasn’t even there at the time, but her comment made it seem as if she was.

Celebrity Traitors’ Joanne McNally made a second bizarre comment that went unnoticed (Credit: BBC)

Ross had said to everyone at the Round Table: “I looked at everybody when we got out of those cars and I thought I was going home.

“And that was honestly, an awful experience.”

Joanne then chipped in, agreeing: “It was horrible, it was…”

Joe Lycett gave her a funny look as Joanne quickly said to the suddenly suspicious group: “I wasn’t there but I heard it…”

But that wasn’t all Joanne said. She went on to make another wild comment that went largely unnoticed.

Celebrity Traitors’ Joanne McNally made second slip up at Round Table

Viewers are likely to have also missed Joanne’s second remark. But thankfully, the team at spin-off show The Celebrity Traitors: Uncloaked spotted it.

In a replay of the scene, Joanne was seen also telling everyone at the Round Table: “I was watching from my cloak”. She even held up her hand, mimicking that she was holding a lantern at the time.

“I was with my lantern!” she said, waving her hand around.

Uncloaked host Ed Gamble appeared stunned watching the bizarre scene back. He said: “The craziest thing for me is that she starts adding details, like going,’With my lantern’.

“No one picked up on that but I would have gone, ‘Oh, so there was a lantern was there?!'”

Joanne McNally pretends to hold a lantern
Joanne said she was ‘watching from her cloak’ as she pretended to hold a lantern (Credit: BBC)

Ed was joined in the Uncloaked studio by Amol Rajan, who was the first celebrity to have been murdered this series.

Giving his take, journalist Amol said: “Can I just say, in that moment, Joanne McNally would have been absolutely panicking. She would have been like, ‘What have I just done?!'”

Ed then made an attempt at trying to work out why Joanne said what she said to Ross.

“She was being empathetic,” he tried to explain. “So what she meant to say was, ‘Oh yeah, it sounds horrible and I feel really bad for you’. But it came out as, ‘Yeah, it was horrible’.”

Ed isn’t the only baffled one. Celebrity Traitors viewers were so confused that they’ve branded Joanne the “worst Faithful ever”.

Do you agree?!

Read more: Celebrity Traitors’ Hannah Fry reveals two mistakes Maya Jama and James Acaster made that could see them rumbled

The Celebrity Traitors continues at 8pm on BBC One on Friday October 16, 2026.