Strictly pro admits Alex Kingston was 'overmarked', declaring she 'would have gone' if there was a public vote

'Three 9s felt a bit generous'
Fabio Magnocavallo

Strictly Come Dancing pro Vincent Simone believes Alex Kingston would have been voted off if there were an elimination on Sunday (November 23).

The Doctor Who actor, who is paired with Johannes Radebe, performed a couple’s choice to History Repeating by Shirley Bassey and Look At Me by Geri Halliwell during Blackpool Week.

The pair received good feedback from judges — Craig Revel Horwood, Motsi Mabuse, Shirley Ballas and Anton Du Beke — who gave high scores.

Craig awarded them an 8. Meanwhile, Motsi, Shirley and Anton Du Beke gave a 9. As a result, Alex and Johannes placed fifth on the leaderboard with a total score of 35.

Vincent Simone smiling
Vincent thinks Alex was ‘overmarked’ (Credit: Splashnews.com)

Strictly star Alex Kingston accused of being ‘overmarked’

Due to La Voix quitting the show following an injury, no one was eliminated on Sunday. However, in an exclusive interview with our sister site, Entertainment Daily, Vincent stated that Balvinder Sopal would have landed in the bottom two alongside Alex if there was a public vote.

“Technically, Balvinder probably would have stayed, and Alex would have gone,” he told ED! on behalf of Paddy Power.

Vincent, who was a pro dancer on the hit show between 2006 and 2012, also didn’t agree with the judges’ scores for the actress.

“Alex was slightly overmarked, too. I saw something off in the lifts, probably due to her injury. Three 9s felt a bit generous,” he said.

Alex Kingston and Johannes Radebe on Strictly
Alex and Johannes were fifth on the leaderboard (Credit: BBC)

‘The judges were raving about her’

On the other hand, another former pro dancer, Brendan Cole, told ED! that he believes Alex would have been saved in the dance off if there was one.

However, he was in agreement that the bottom two would have likely been between Alex and Balvinder.

“Balvinder Sopal would have gone home – if La Voix hadn’t been injured. The judges were raving about her, and I don’t think it was very good,” Brendan said on behalf of Sky Vegas.

He insisted that “Alex Kingston and Johannes Radebe were quite weak too”, adding: “It would have been a dance-off between those two couples, and Balvinder would have gone.”

Read more: Strictly star Shirley Ballas shares health update after she ‘almost died’ 20 minutes before live show

Strictly Come Dancing continues at 6.35pm on BBC One and BBC iPlayer on Saturday, November 29, 2025.