ITV Share By Jade Brown Jun 30 2025 By Jade Brown Jun 30 2025 Emmerdale fans ‘work out’ major soap crossover ‘clue’ that could expose John Sugden’s true identity Is John from another soap universe? Coronation Street and Emmerdale Crossover John Sugden John's Secret Life Share By Jade Brown Jun 30 2025 By Jade Brown Jun 30 2025 Emmerdale fans believe they have discovered the true identity of John Sugden – and it involves the special crossover episode. It was announced earlier this year that ITV will be airing a special episode which sees Emmerdale crossing over with Coronation Street. Fans are now convinced that John isn’t a Sugden at all, but in fact has links to the Street instead. When will John be exposed? (Credit: ITV) John’s big secret in Emmerdale John Sugden arrived in Emmerdale last August as the long lost brother of Victoria. From the off, John had a question mark above his head and has continued to keep secrets. Namely that he has a hero complex, which sees him put people in danger and then lap up the praise when he saves them. article continues below Read all the latest spoilers John’s list of victims is a long one, including Chas, Liam and Seb. But the worst crime of all saw him accidentally kill Nate Robinson. After John injected Nate with a substance, with the intention of bringing him back round and saving his life, Nate suffered a reaction and passed away. John threw Nate’s body in the river, but that was recently discovered. Nate’s wife Tracy and dad Cain were the immediate suspects – with John offering them both support. John recently married Aaron Dingle, but Robert Sugden is back on the scene and intent on splitting the pair up. Fans initially suspected that Robert would be the one to discover John’s lies, but now they have a new theory – and it’s wild! Fans are eager for John to be exposed (Credit: ITV) Emmerdale fan theory predicts John Sugden identity twist Avid soap fans will remember that actor Oliver Farnworth, who plays John in Emmerdale, previously played a character in Coronation Street called Andy Carver. Andy was a friend of Michael Rodwell’s son Gavin, but after the pair fell out, Andy decided to pose as Gavin. Andy formed a close bond with Michael and following Michael’s death he set out to get revenge on Pat Phelan, who he correctly guessed was responsible. Things didn’t go to plan though and Andy was abducted by Phelan. After being kept in the basement for months, Phelan shot Andy dead. But fans have suggested that perhaps Andy didn’t really die. Taking to Facebook, one viewer had an idea. They wrote: “Emmerdale have been absolutely genius with casting Oliver Farnworth. On Corrie, he portrayed a character with a false identity and claimed to be Gavin, the son of Michael Rodwell played by Les Dennis, later to be known as Andy Carver. “I think Emmerdale are still keeping the false ID storyline with the character, but instead of being the victim, he is obviously the murderer. A lot will be uncovered about John’s background soon! I don’t think John is who he says he is and it’ll get very dark.” Another fan added: “Maybe Andy didn’t die and he’s actually come to the Dales as John instead.” While a third said: “Emmerdale and Corrie are to merge for a storyline. First time ever. Could this be where it happens?” Read more: Who’s leaving Emmerdale in 2025? A complete guide to departures, returns and new arrivals in the Dales Share this: Click to share on X (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) Good to Know Share By Jade Brown Jun 30 2025 By Jade Brown Jun 30 2025
